Freedivers' Information for proposed

Southern California Closures

Santa Barbara Area

Santa Barbara Area Freediver’s MLPA Concerns By Matt Bond 

I: General

 

1) All recreational areas designated as “Shore-based, hook and line fishing only” must also include spearfishing.  Logic:  Spearfishermen are more selective than hook and line fishermen.  We actually see what we catch before we catch it.  If a certain species is protected, we definitely won’t catch it;  a hook and line fishermen might. 

In both the Conception SMP and the Carpinteria SMP, the DFG says that “shore-based, hook and line fishing” is permitted in order to minimize impact on recreation.  Spearfishermen impact the resource the least, so we too need to be protected from the consequences of  the park designation. 

2) The term “Shore-based recreational activities” must include fishing from small skiffs, paddle boards, surf skis, kayaks, and other relatively small floatation platforms.    Logic:  Many areas, such as Carpinteria Reef, are far from shore.  Divers use these different types of floatation devices to safely access fishing grounds.  Kayaks and the like help spearfishermen to be seen by boats, which prevents us from being run over.  They also allow us to safely store our catch, and let us bring water, food and first aid supplies along when we dive. 

3)Sustenance fishing in areas close to neighborhoods, like the Coal Oil Point SMR, should never be restricted.  Logic:  There are members of the population who do not own cars or boats and who get a significant part of their daily protein intake from “sport-caught” fish and invertebrates, which they catch in areas that are within walking distance from their homes.   People need to feed themselves. 

4)Areas that permit the take of lobster should also afford the take of crabs, cockles, clams, limpets, whelk, turban snails, octopus, mussels, scallops, urchin, sea cucumber, and any other invertebrate or algae that the master plan team or DFG do not consider threatened by fishing pressure.     Logic:  Many people eat a variety of invertebrates and algae.  Unless threatened, there is no purpose of excluding the harvest of anything under the Park and Conservation area designation.

 

Back to the Freediver's California Closure Index